Dynaudio BM5a's Vs Mackie Hr624's (monitors)

[Gopal]

F5D you have made some very good points that I think too many people in the industry misunderstand/overlook.

I work in the hi-fi industry and just as you said, the goal of hi fi is to accurately reproduce the source material. Everyone says "don't use hi fi speakers for monitoring cause they are 'coloured'. Well, newsflash guys, EVERYTHING is coloured. If they weren't then the Mackies and the Dynaudios would sound exactly the same as the KRKs and Events. But they all have their own character or 'colour'.

Besides you will find that Sony New York, Abbey Road and Lucas Films all mix and master their recordings on high end hi fi speakers and don't use studio monitors at all! B&W Nautilus 800 Diamond series speakers to be precise.

Worth pointing out that the whole point of everyone using NS10s is that they are such an aweful sounding speaker that if you get a mix sounding good on them, it will translate to a good mix on anything.

[Tomer=Trance]

I belive its different when you record,mix and master for motion pictures (film) since you know that result is not intended for an Ipod or home radio, but intended for very expensive surround systems at cinemas.
the chance of a mix not to translate well minimizes... but belive them they do check over and over before shiping\printing the movie.

[Gopal]

Sony New York and Abbey Road don't use them for film at all just for mixing and mastering stereo and SACD/DVD-A surround music discs

[~+?]

Most of the installations at Abbey Road are Quested BTW! Roger Quested is the in house acoustic engineer for Abbey Road, also one of the top engineers there. Search for Pink Floyd and Roger Quested and Abbey.
http://www.rogerwaters.org/abrdstory.html
http://www.abbeyroad.co.uk/studio2/

[~+?]

For surround Abbey use Quested front and back they have the rather expensive Nautilus Loudspeakers!

[Trance Explorer]

http://www.googlefight.com/index.php...o&word2=mackie

[jonbon]

Bought bm6a couple of years ago, never looked back. I can sit for hours infront of them just listening to good music. In fact, they are my favourite pieces of gear!

Buuut, on the other hand this overwhelming googlefightloss, has turned me around to considering the mackies again! 8O

[Trance Explorer]

I choose all my gear with googlefight!



But tbh both Mackie and Dynaudio are amazing speakers, you cant go wrong with either

[juno_nuno]

Originally Posted by Trance Explorer

I choose all my gear with googlefight!



But tbh both Mackie and Dynaudio are amazing speakers, you cant go wrong with either

I had some doubts but now im sure